Wild Horses Face Mass Slaughter Due to Overpopulation on the Great Plains

December 28, 2012

AWHC Contributor

Wild horses, iconic symbols of the American West, are facing a dire situation due to overpopulation and rising management costs. The current system, in place since 1971, is struggling to cope, leading to potential mass slaughter of these majestic animals.

They are an icon of the American West and a symbol of the country's frontier history, but now hundreds of mustang horses face slaughter due to overpopulation.

Under existing laws, the government pays ranchers to take in thousands of these 'wild' horses a year to keep population numbers down. Mustangs are not an indigenous species to America and are known to have an adverse effect on natural ecosystems.

The current system of managing these threats has been in place since 1971, but now rising feed costs have resulted in a growing number of American ranchers refusing to take on mustangs.

Officials have warned that the government's own holding pastures and short-term corrals are themselves reaching overcapacity.

The result could mean that thousands of this treasured breed will be slaughtered to contain overpopulation.

Across ten western states in the US, an estimated 37,000 wild horses and feral donkeys roam the ranges.

Officials say this is 11,000 more than the manageable population, and it is expected that figures will double every four years.

There are around 50,000 wild horses and donkeys currently held in temporary pastures, three times the amount held a decade ago.

Despite the crisis in overpopulation and the known effects of wild horses on natural habitats of other native animals, activists continue to battle with the government over its management of mustangs in particular.

To thin the populations of wild herds, helicopters are used to chase mustangs into traps. Some campaigners think this is cruel and damaging to a species they believe America should be protecting.

Suzanne Roy of the American Wild Horse Conservation (formerly American Wild Horse Preservation) said that pregnant mares and foals are stampeded by helicopters over miles of rugged terrain.

'Helicopters aren't discerning,' she said. 'They stampede the very old and the very young with the fit.'

Authorities have been accused of managing mustangs into extinction. However, only 99 out of the 11,000 gathered from the plains last year died. That's less than 1%.

Officials are now beginning to recognize that slaughter might be the only solution to contain the population.

Ms. Roy denies this and questions the wisdom surrounding the belief that America's land cannot support mustang populations.

She claims that the legislation is weighted heavily in favor of the ranchers who need the land freed up for cattle.

The problem could be better addressed through contraceptive measures using fertility drugs.

Tom Gorey, of the Bureau of Land Management, denied that this would provide an adequate alternative.

He said: 'Logistically, [contraception] is very hard. It has not been demonstrated to be a magical solution.'

The US Congress has recognized the mustang as 'a living symbol of the historic and pioneer spirit of the West.'

The first Mustangs descended from Iberian horses brought to Mexico and Florida from Spain during the settlement of North America.

Most of these horses were of Andalusian, Arabian, and Barb ancestry and were domesticated animals tamed for human use.

This has led to a dispute over whether it is entirely accurate to call the mustang 'wild' since it is the descendant of a domestic breed which is not native to the natural habitat.

Native Americans quickly adopted the horse as a primary means of transportation. They were also used in battles, trade, and hunts, particularly bison hunts.

Some environmentalists claim that the mustang should be classed as indigenous because there is evidence that horses roamed North America in prehistoric times.

More than half of all Mustangs in North America are found in Nevada, with other significant populations in Montana, Wyoming, and Oregon.

The government says that the total manageable population in the wild should be 26,000, a figure that is significantly lower than the reality.